Efficacy and Safety of Magnesium versus Dexmedetomidine as Additives to Local Anesthetic Mixture Using Single Injection Percutaneous Peribulbar Anesthesia in Vitreoretinal Surgeries

1. INTRODUCTION

Vitreoretinal surgeries are one of the commonest operation performed across the world, they are deemed to be long and uncomfortable for patients to tolerate. The vast majority of these procedures can be safe, comfortable, efficient and performed under properly monitored local anesthesia. Local analgesic adjuvants are used to enhance the nature of local anesthesia for enhancement of akinesia onset, prolong the duration and decrease the postoperative pain, added substances like hyaluronidase, adrenaline, clonidine; sodium bicarbonate, corticosteroids and neuromuscular blocking drugs have been utilized as a part of peribulbar block with a limited rate of success [1-6].

Magnesium sulfate has been utilized for a long time with local anesthetic solutions in various techniques of regional anesthesia to decrease the onset time of the blockade and to enhance the quality and duration of anesthesia; such impacts are basically based on physiological calcium opposition and noncompetitive antagonist of N-methyl-D-Aspartate (NMDA) receptors [7] dexmedetomidine is centrally acting highly specific α2-agonist commonly used as sedative, preemptive analgesic and proved to decrease the onset of anesthesia and increase the duration of analgesia and akinesia in neuroaxial and regional blocks [8]. Both of them were tested in different concentrations as adjuvant to peribulbar anesthesia and their benefits regarding the quality of the block were tested in several studies [9, 10].

In order to find best local anesthetic adjuvant with least complication and best cost-benefit with simple technique, we compared the effect of addition of Magnesium sulphate vs dexmedetomidine to standard local Anesthetics mixtures on the time of onset of Globe Anesthesia, Akinesia and their duration with pain relief to suit the relatively long vitreoretinal surgeries producing optimal operating conditions.

2. MATERIALS AND METHODS:

This prospective randomized, double-blind, and controlled study was conducted on 90 patients ASA I - III, age ranged between 25 and 75 years and scheduled for elective vitreoretinal surgery under local peribulbar anesthesia. Participants were enrolled from March 2016 to December 2017 at Ain Shams University Hospitals. Patient informed written consent and Local Ethical Committee approval have been obtained before patient’s allocation.

Exclusion criteria included age younger than 18 years, coagulopathy, communication problems, or allergy to any of the study medications. Furthermore, patients were excluded if they had the severe cardiac disease, chronic obstructive lung disease, and a history of sleep apnea.

These patients were randomly allocated using closed envelopes into 3 equal groups (n 30):

Control Group (Group C): Received mixture of Levo-bupivacaine

0.5% (3 ml) + lidocaine 2% (3ml) +120 IU hyaluronidase + 0.5 ml of Normal saline.

Magnesium sulphate Group (M): Received mixture of Levo-bupivacaine

0.5% (3 ml) + lidocaine 2% (3ml) +120 IU hyaluronidase + 50 mg of Magnesium sulphate (50 mg in 0.5-ml saline).

Dexmedetomidine Group (D): Received mixture of Levo-bupivacaine

0.5% (3 ml) + lidocaine 2% (3 ml) +120 IU hyaluronidase + 50 µg of dexmedetomidine (50 mic in 0.5-ml saline).

All patients received single-injection percutaneous peribulbar block by an experienced anesthesiologist, and both the patient and the anesthesiologist were blinded to the drug mixture used.

Patients arrived in the operating room unpremedicated and having fasted for the preceding 8 hours. A peripheral IV cannula was inserted; and standard monitoring, including Noninvasive Arterial Blood Pressure (NIBP), electrocardiogram (5 leads), Heart Rate (HR) and peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO₂) were used.

The injection site was percutaneous and limited superiorly by the inferior lacrimal canaliculus, medially by the lateral margin of the nose, laterally by imaginary perpendicular line joining inferior lacrimal papilla to the inferior margin of the orbit and inferiorly by the inferior margin of the orbit. The needle was advanced in an anteroposterior direction for half of its length and then obliquely in the direction of the optical foramen, as described by Rizzo et al. [11].

The needle used was a 25-gauge, 16-mm, short-bevel needle. After negative aspiration, 6.5 mL of the local anesthetic solution was slowly injected.

Gentle ocular massage was applied intermittently to eyeball to promote the local anesthetic spread at the same time IOP was measured using indentation tonometry before injection and 1, 5, 10 minutes after injection.

Corneal sensation was evaluated using cotton wick every 30 seconds till the onset of anesthesia and every 30 minutes till recovery.

The degree of globe and lid akinesia was evaluated in the 4 quadrants using a 3 point scoring system described by Sarvela: (0 = complete akinesia, 1= partial akinesia, 2 = normal movements) the time for complete akinesia (0) was recorded in all patients. The presence of ocular anesthesia together with globe & lid akinesia score ≤ 1 was considered satisfactory to start the surgery. If inadequate motor block is observed 10 minutes after block, supplementary anesthesia of 3 ml of lidocaine 2% was injected into the involved quadrant.

Supplemental O₂ at 2 L/min via nasal cannula was used throughout the procedure.

The following measures were assessed:

1. The duration of sensory and motor block: by the onset of pain and recovery of the eyeball movement respectively. Using a 5 point Verbal Rating Scale (VRS) recorded intra operatively every 30 min and postoperatively every 2 h for 6 h after the operation (0= no pain, 1= mild pain, 2= moderate pain, 3= severe pain and 4= unbearable pain). If VRS score ≥ 2 was reported intraoperatively additional supplementary local anesthesia subtenon’s block was administered while postoperatively ketolorac 30 mg intramuscular is given.
2. Sedation levels: with modified Ramsay sedation scale: (1- Anxious and agitated, 2- cooperative, tranquil, 3- responds to commands, 4- brisk response to light tap or loud) 15 min during surgery and every 30 min during first 2 hours postoperatively.
3. Intra-ocular Pressure (IOP): Before injection of LA (baseline) and after a complete akinesia of the globe before surgical incision.
4. Patients’ hemodynamics: Heart Rate (HR) and mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) recorded every 5 min during the surgery and in the immediate postoperative period (at 15 and 30 min).
5. Adverse effects or complications related to the technique and the drugs used e.g. bradycardia (if heart rate decrease less than 50 b/m), hypotension (if decrease 30% in baseline mean BP), globe perforation, hemorrhage are recorded and managed if present (bradycardia will be treated by atropine 0.5 mg to be repeated if no response till 3 mg, increment dose of ephedrine in case of hypotension as it usually temporally effect.
6. Surgeon satisfaction: at the end of the surgery using a simple verbal scale (1= satisfied, 0 = unsatisfied).

3. RESULTS

The demographic data showed no statistically significant differences in patient characteristics as regards age, sex, American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status, and duration of surgery.

There was no statically significant difference between groups as regards patient and surgery satisfaction. Also, there was no change in the sedation level after the peribulbar block and during the whole surgery in any of the three groups in comparison with the pre-block state. However, Regarding the need for supplementary injection there was statistical significance between the M & D group when compared to the C group (Table 1).

4. DISCUSSION

Peribulbar block is commonly used for vitreoretinal surgery in adult but using traditional mix of local anesthetic drugs (bupivacaine 0.5% + lidocaine 2%) for peribulbar anesthesia is usually associated with delayed onset of globe akinesia and corneal anesthesia, short duration of analgesia and frequent need of block supplementation, to overcome this obstacle many adjutants were added to local anesthesia. In our study, we planned to compare between dexmedetomidine and Magnesium sulphate as an adjuvant to local anesthetic mixture using the single injection technique for percutaneous peribulbar anesthesia with a short needle as described by Rizzo et al. [11] it has been proved to be a simple and easy-to-perform technique with less pain, using a decreased volume of local anesthetic. The hypothesis of the efficacy of this technique was revealed in previous studies [12] using B-scan ultrasonography which demonstrated that a small volume of local anesthetics diffused circumferentially from the extraconal to the intraconal space, where the sensory and motor nerves of the eye are located [13].

In the study, ninety patients were allocated in three equal groups (30 each), group C (control group), group M (50 mg magnesium sulphate added to the LA mixture), and group D (50 µg of dexmedetomidine added to the LA mixture).

The Magnesium group (group M) showed rapid onset to establish the block than the dexmedetomidine and control groups leading to less delay in surgery and more suitable conditions to operate in less than 10 mins. El-Hamid [14] proved that magnesium had a significant rapid onset of globe and lid akinesia when compared with clonidine as an adjuvant to local anesthetic in peribulbar block for posterior segment eye surgeries. Also, Narang et al. [15] observed that the addition of magnesium sulfate as adjunct to lignocaine for total intravenous anesthesia for upper limb surgery enhanced the onset of sensory and motor block and decreased tourniquet pain.

In contrast, Lee et al. [16] observed no difference in onset times and duration of sensory and motor blocks in magnesium sulfate group and normal saline group with 0.5% bupivacaine with epinephrine in interscalene nerve block for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. They only found statistically significant prolongation of analgesia in the magnesium group than in the saline group. Also, Tamer and Bestarous [17] compared the use of Magnesium sulfate with that of Rocuronium as an adjuvant to the local anesthetic in peribulbar anesthesia for cataract surgery, they reported that the addition of magnesium sulfate did not show any benefit as regards the onset of the block.

Whereas in another study by Hala and Ayman [18], who studied the effect of adding two different doses of dexmedetomidine (25 µg and 50 µg) to Levo-bupivacaine/hyaluronidase mixture and assessed their effects on the onset and duration of globe anesthesia and akinesia, they found out that both doses significantly enhanced the onset of corneal anesthesia and globe akinesia than in the control group but the 25 µg group had better hemodynamic stability.

In our study, the dexmedetomidine group showed prolonged duration of the block reflected as prolonged post-operative analgesia rather than M group or C group. This goes with Channabasappa et al. [19] who found out that patients who received 25 µg dexmedetomidine added to their anesthetic mixture used in the peribulbar block, showed a statistically significant increase in the duration of akinesia compared to the group of patients who received only the local anesthetic mixture. Also, in Reem and Khashaba [20] study, the duration of globe analgesia and globe akinesia showed a statistically significant increase in both groups of study (the clonidine group and dexmedetomidine group) in comparison with the control group. But this advantage doesn’t have a statistical impact on patient or surgery satisfaction.

Regarding the IOP, the addition of magnesium or dexmedetomidine to the local anesthetic mixture in group M and group D showed a statistically significant decrease in the IOP 5 min and 10 min after the injection of the local anesthetic mixture when compared to the baseline measurement of the same groups and the control group. While no significant differences were detected when comparing the IOP 5 min and 10 min in both M and D groups. These results were correlating with those of Hafez et al. [9] and El-Raouf et al. [10], where they found that the addition of magnesium and dexmedetomidine to LA mixture caused a statistically significant decrease in IOP compared to control group at 1, 5, and 10 min.

There were no adverse effects or complications related to the technique and the drugs used, the patients were hemodynamically stable throughout the procedure this could be attributed to small doses of the drug used also there was no difference between the groups regarding the patient’s sedation level, furthermore both surgeon and patients satisfaction were almost the same between the three groups. However, regarding the need of supplementary injection there was statistical significance between the M & D group when compared to the C group but there was no statistical significance between the M & D groups which further justify their effectiveness as adjuvants in extending the sensory and the motor block duration.

Although, the number of patients and using single type of ophthalmic surgery with fixed concentrations could be a limitation to our study, however, the significant decrease in IOP caused by magnesium and dexmedetomidine should be further investigated, this advantage opens research gate to be useful in glaucoma surgery.

CONCLUSION

Adding 50 mg Magnesium sulphate to a mixture of lidocaine 2% and bupivacaine in peribulbar block shortened sensory and motor block onset, and extended the analgesia period and the motor block duration. It also significantly decreased the intraocular pressure and enabled better operation conditions. It is comparable and safe as adding dexmedetomidine but better as cost-effectiveness and availability rather than dexmedetomidine in our country.

REFERENCES