Breath-holding Test in the Prognosis of Postoperative Pain in Laparoscopic Gynecology: Observational Cohort Study

1. INTRODUCTION

The problem of perioperative pain relief has not lost its relevance over the years. Studies have shown that between 30% and up to 80% of patients report moderate to severe pain in the days after surgery [1]. The evolution of minimally invasive methods in surgery, including for diagnosis and treatment, has led to a sharp and significant change in surgical practice in treating various types of diseases [2, 3]. Minimally invasive surgery, including laparoscopic surgery, has become widely accepted and has partly replaced traditional laparotomic surgical procedures in the treatment of various types of benign gynecological diseases [4].

Minimally invasive surgery, including gynecology, has a number of advantages, such as a significant reduction in surgical trauma, less severe pain associated with a postoperative wound, less use of systemic analgesics, better cosmetic results, shorter hospital stay, shorter recovery time and earlier return to daily activities and work compared to laparotomy [5, 6]. Despite these benefits, up to 80% of patients (35% to 80%) still experience severe pain after laparoscopic gynecologic surgery and require pain relief for mild to excruciating discomfort [7]. Pain syndrome after laparoscopic procedures has a specific pathophysiological mechanism, including inflammatory changes associated with surgical trauma and skin incision and morphological and biochemical changes in the peritoneum and diaphragm associated with pneumoperitoneum.

In recent years, great interest among specialists has been focused on the role of baroreflex sensitivity in the functional state of the nociceptive and antinociceptive systems. Increasing evidence suggests that baroreflex arc pathways also project to key central nervous system (CNS) that regulate somatosensory, somatomotor, and CNS arousal. In addition to maintaining autonomic homeostasis, baroreceptor activity modulates pain perception and neuroimmune, neuroendocrine, and cognitive responses to physical and psychological stressors [8]. The progression of chronic concomitant diseases is invariably accompanied by impaired baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) [9]. In recent years, leading researchers have shown increasing interest in determining the role of this factor in assessing the risk of unfavorable outcomes of the disease and the perioperative period [10-12]. Studies have shown that a test with maximum breath-holding during inspiration allows for a non-invasive and accurate assessment of the functional state of the cardiorespiratory system, making it possible to identify a cohort of patients with reduced baroreflex sensitivity [13].

The study aimed to assess the relationship between the breath-holding test and postoperative pain and to develop a model for predicting pain after laparoscopic gynecological surgery.

2. METHODOLOGY

We used a cohort study design to identify risk factors for the development of severe postoperative pain and the role of the breath-holding test in predicting pain after laparoscopic gynecology.

Data from 489 patients undergoing gynecological laparoscopy at the Clinic of the Kuban State Medical University from August 2019 to September 2023 were analyzed. Preoperatively, upon examination by the anesthesiologist, patients were sequentially assessed for inclusion in the study and, in the absence of exclusion criteria, were included in the study. Patients were followed up until postoperative day 2. This prospective clinical observational study was conducted according to the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Local Ethics Committee in Kuban Medical University (No. 76 from 29.03.2019); patients signed informed voluntary consent before the recruitment to the study.

2.6. Statistical Analysis

Based on planning for the inclusion of up to 5 risk factors in the final prognostic model and a severe postoperative pain rate of 30%, the required number of patients wasapproximately 500 patients. To assess the nature of the distribution, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used. Data are presented as means, medians, and interquartile ranges. Categorical data were analyzed with Fisher’s exact test or χ2 test, and risk estimates were calculated using odds ratio and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Continuous variables were assessed with the Mann–Whitney U test. Repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine differences in pain severity across time points. Spearman's correlation coefficient was used to assess the association of factors with pain severity. Logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of severe pain. The abilities of a model to predict severe acute pain (NRS 7–10) were measured using ROC analysis. Cut-off values used for the calculation of sensitivity and specificity were calculated based on goodness of fit (highest combined sensitivity and specificity).

Table 1.

Parameter	All Patients (n=489)	Severe Pain (n=146)	Low/moderate Pain (n=343)	p
Age	36 (30-45)	35 (32-45)	36 (31-47)	0.454
Weight (kg)	63 (56-74)	61 (52-73)	64 (51-72)	0.210
BMI (kg/m2)	26 (24-29)	25 (22-28)	26 (24-29)	0.45
ASA score	1 (1-1)	1 (1-1)	1 (1-1)	0.85
Breath-holding test (sec)	42 (36-48)	39 (31-44)	44 (38-49)	<0.0001
PHQ-9	2 (2-3)	2 (2-3)	2 (1-3)	0.0310
GAD7	2 (2-3)	2 (0-6)	2 (0-3)	0.0024
PSC	11 (7-12)	11 (9-15)	10 (7-12)	0.0002
Preoperative NRS	1 (1-2)	1 (1-2)	1 (1-2)	0.25
Operation time	50 (30-75)	60 40-90)	45 (30-65)	<0.0001
Surgical Procedure
Hysterectomy	150	28	122	0,0003
Endometriosis surgery	112	72	40	<0,0001
Adnexectomy	78	13	65	0,026
Diagnostic laparoscopy	65	11	54	0,016
Myoma enucleation	50	12	38	0,32
Other	34	10	24	0,95

Table 2.

Time Point	Correlation Coefficient	CI95%	p
NRS-PACU	-0,18	-0,26 - -0,10	<0,0001
NRS 15 min	-0,18	-0,26 - -0,10	<0,0001
NRS 30 min	-0,18	-0,26- -0,09	<0,0001
NRS ward	-0,15	-0,223- -0,06	0,0007
NRS 6h	-0,18	-0,27 - -0,09	<0,0001
NRS D2	-0,21	-0,30 – 0,13	<0,0001

Note: NRS-PACU - at the PACU, NRS 15 min - 15 minutes after admitting to the PACU, NRS 30 min - 30 minutes after admitting to the PACU, NRS ward - at a discharge from PACU to the ward, NRS 6h - 6 hours after surgery, NRS D2 - at a study visit on the first postoperative day.

3. RESULTS

A total of 489 patients were included in the analysis. Severe postoperative pain was reported in 146 patients (29.9%). Preoperative parameters for the study groups and the structure of surgical interventions are presented in Table 1.

The duration of the breath-holding test was statistically significantly lower in patients with severe postoperative pain. Also, its duration was statistically significantly correlated with NRS upon admission to the PACU at all time points of the study (Table 2).

However, ROC analysis showed that the breath-holding test alone has insufficient predictive value (Fig. 2).

The logistic regression performed allowed us to identify factors influencing the risk of developing severe postoperative pain. These include the duration of the breath-holding test, scores on the PSC and GAD7 scales, the duration of the surgery, and the type of operation - endometriosis surgery. Table 3 shows the logistic regression equation (Nagelkerke R² 0.37).

The Hosmer–Lemeshow test showed a goodness of fit for the logistic regression model (Chi-squared 5.4, P = 0.7110). ROC analysis showed a good prognostic value for the model (area under the ROC curve (AUC) 0.809, standard error 0.022, 95% confidence interval 0.771 to 0.842). ROC are shown in Fig. (3).

The cut-off point was >39,1% for the risk of severe postoperative pain (sensitivity 62,33% and specificity 87,76%).

Retrospectively, all patients in the study cohort were divided into two groups according to the developed model - patients with a high (>39.1%) and low risk (39.1% or less) of severe postoperative pain. The proportion of patients with NRS 7 or more was 15.4% in the low-risk group and 68.4% (<0.0001) in the high-risk group (Fig. 4). High-risk and low-risk patients were different in GAD7 (2(2-4) vs. 2 (2-2), p<0.0001), PSC (12 (10-17) vs. 11 (8-12), p<0.0001), breath-holding duration (44 (43-47) sec vs. 38 (35-40) sec, p<0.0001), duration of procedure (45 (30-55) min vs. 65 (50-75) min, p<0.0001) and endometriosis rate (18% vs. 35%, p<0.0001). PHQ-9 (2 (2-2) vs. 2(2-2), p=0.26), preoperative pain ((1 (1-2) vs. 1 (1-2) and age (35 (31-44) vs. 36 (32-46), p=0.47) were comparable between high-risk and low-risk groups.

Pain levels also varied between groups. At all time points, the NRS score was statistically significantly higher in the high-risk group (Table 4).

Median morphine consumption at 1 h postoperatively was 5,5 mg (3,9–8,7) in the low-risk group and 7.4 mg (5.1–10.1) in the high-risk group (p = 0.006) and was also significantly different at 6 h (11.2 (8.3–18.0) vs. 17.0 (10.2–24.7) mg; p = 0.001) and on postoperative day 2 (19.0 (11.0–30.1) vs. 26.0 (17.0–38.2) mg; p = 0.003), respectively.

4. DISCUSSION

Our data indicate that the incidence of severe postoperative pain is 29.9% in laparoscopic gynecology, while the duration of the breath-holding test has a certain prognostic value in assessing the risk of its development and, along with other predictors, can be useful in clinical practice.

Although minimally invasive surgery has traditionally been presented as an area with less postoperative pain, this is not always true. As shown by a study by Gerbershagen et al. [18], laparoscopic gynecological surgery was associated with a relatively high level of pain (median NRS 5 (3-7)) and a high need for opioids, practically not inferior to the pain after open operations and exceeding the pain from, for example, open right hemicolectomy. Also, laparoscopic gynecological surgeries have been associated with more pain than laparoscopic surgical procedures (e.g., cholecystectomy). In addition, pain after laparoscopic surgery is often underestimated, and in this category of patients, opioids are used much less frequently for the treatment of postoperative pain. Previous studies have shown that risk factors include female gender, young age, and preoperative pain [20-22], which partly explains the authors' findings. However, even within this population, the pattern of postoperative pain severity is varied, and there are other factors that influence its intensity. Our study showed that pain is relatively high in laparoscopic gynecology, even despite the use of opioids. The median NRS in the overall group was 4 (2-6) on admission to the PACU, which is slightly less than in the study by Gerbershagen HJ et al. [18] and is explained by the variety of procedures in our research. High-risk patients had higher pain intensity at comparable ages and preoperative pain levels.

The type of surgical intervention, as indicated above, was often identified as a predictor of severe postoperative pain. In our study, the type of laparoscopic gynecology was included in the regression model, and only endometriosis surgery had a significant effect on postoperative pain. This fact can hardly be considered surprising; endometriosis is a complex disease that is often associated with pain, including chronic pain. This is a common gynecological disease with an incidence of up to 10% in fertile women. Its development is associated with the presence of endometrium outside the uterine cavity; the disease has its own characteristic neuroendocrine and inflammatory features [23, 24]. The pattern following from our results is different from the data obtained by Kanellos et al. [25], who concluded that it is preoperative pain, and not endometriosis itself, that increases the severity of postoperative pain. Van Aken et al. [26], however, believe that the pathogenesis of pain in endometriosis has its own specifics, and women suffering from this disease are less tolerant of painful sensations in the pelvic area, which may be the reason for more severe pain in the postoperative period. Length of surgery has also been identified as a predictor of severe postoperative pain. An increase in pain over time may be due to greater trauma, as well as the influence of infiltration anesthesia, the effect of which is limited in time. Suragul et al. showed that the effect of local anesthesia at trocar sites is significantly reduced if the duration of anesthesia exceeds 2 hours [27].

The role of psycho-emotional factors in the severity of postoperative pain plays a significant role in gynecology. There were significant correlations between baseline pain and psychological measures of distress pre-operatively [28]. Wong et al. also found that the PHQ-9, GAD-7, and PCS scales are associated with the severity of postoperative pain [29]. Catastrophizing pain is often a factor not only in severe postoperative pain but also a predictor of the transition from acute pain to chronic pain in various areas of surgery, including gynecology [30-32]. In our study, only GAD-7 and PCS were associated with pain. These data suggest that the psychoemotional component of pain is an important factor and a potential target for multimodal analgesia methods used in the perioperative period.

To our knowledge from the literature review, this is the first study to evaluate the ability of the breath-holding test to determine the risk of postoperative pain, and it showed that the duration of the breath-holding test is negatively correlated with pain severity.

The role of baroreflex blood pressure control in perioperative outcomes has recently received much attention. Baroreflex dysfunction before surgery is detected quite often, especially in patients with a number of concomitant cardiac and respiratory diseases, such as hypertension [33], diabetes [34], carotid atherosclerosis [35, 36], obesity [37], in smokers [38], high alcohol consumption [39] and obstructive sleep apnea [40]. Baroreflex dysfunction and autonomic nervous system imbalance modulate local and systemic inflammatory processes in animal experiments [41]. Autonomic regulation of inflammatory mediators acts directly on nociceptors or indirectly on sympathetic nerve endings, producing and releasing inflammatory substances that contribute to pain perception [42]. In addition, afferent pain signaling may directly modulate other components of inflammation, including plasma extravasation and neutrophil function, which are modulated by vagal afferent activity [43]. The role of the sympathetic nervous system in the development of hyperalgesia has also been demonstrated in humans [44]. Several clinical studies have demonstrated the role of baroreflex sensitivity on pain severity. Thus, a prospective study found that low baroreflex sensitivity was associated with a higher NRS score in the first 6 weeks after hand surgery [45]. There is also work indicating that preoperative resting blood pressure and, presumably, arterial baroreflex sensitivity is associated with the intensity of postoperative pain at 24 hours and 48 hours after prostatectomy and after cesarean section [46, 47]. The relationship between the baroreflex and pain is discussed in more detail in the review by Suarez-Roca H et al. [8]. As fundamental research has shown, the breath-holding test reflects the sensitivity of the baroreflex [13], which explains the patterns obtained in our study.

Limitations. The breath-holding test is a surrogate marker of the functional state of the reflex regulation of the cardiorespiratory system and may also reflect the psycho-emotional state of patients. However, in the present work, it was shown to be a factor independently influencing the level of pain. Secondly, the study was conducted at a single center, and anesthesia was provided by different specialists whose contribution was not assessed, and these results need external validation. The obtained patterns reflect the characteristics of postoperative pain syndrome in laparoscopic gynecology. For open operations, the analgesia strategy may be different, as well as the duration of the operation. On the other hand, laparoscopic operations in other areas of surgery may also have characteristics associated with the nature of the underlying disease, gender, and age characteristics.

CONCLUSION

The breath-holding test, along with other factors, may be useful in assessing the risk of severe postoperative pain after laparoscopic gynecology. Factors such as the duration of the operation, endometriosis surgery, the degree of inclusion of emotional and behavioral components in the structure of the pain syndrome according to the pain catastrophizing scale and anxiety, which we determined using the GAD-7 scale, also contribute to the development of severe pain.

REFERENCES